Wednesdays with Winemakers – James MacPhail 4 min read

James MacPhail is an avid adventurer, traveler, accomplished classical pianist, bagpiper, competitive swimmer and polo player.


In the 90s, James began his winemaking journey by working with stellar growers in Sonoma County. During this period, he fell in love with Pinot Noir. MacPhail Family Wines was born in 2002. He immediately received accolades from Wine Spectator, trade and consumers, who loved his small lot, superbly crafted Pinot Noirs.


He selects his vineyard sources with the utmost care, choosing to work with growers who farm sustainably and work with him to “cultivate” the wine in the vineyards. As a winemaker, he prefers traditional methods. Showing profound respect for preserving integrity of the fruit, he practices low intervention in the cellar.


Today, MacPhail Pinot Noirs from Anderson Valley, Eola-Amity Hills, Green Valley, Russian River Valley, Sonoma Coast, Sta. Rita Hills, along with his Sonoma Coast Chardonnays, are highly prized by perspicacious consumers. James’ continuing passion for his craft shows through by way of these gorgeous wines.


Why did you become a vintner/winemaker?

From an early age, wine always fascinated me – its history, the farming aspect, and the fact that you could make an agricultural product from the earth that brought joy to so many people. Always thought that was really cool. I did not ever expect to be where I am today, it just happened – with lots of hard work, sacrifice, and a bit of timing.


If you weren’t a vintner/winemaker what would you be and why?

Professional baseball player. Making a living by going to the ballpark every day, and running out onto that green grass field to play baseball, I mean, what kid/adult wouldn’t want to get paid doing that?!


What is your greatest strength as a vintner/winemaker?

Attention to detail & the desire to learn more.


What is your biggest weakness as a vintner/winemaker?

The in-depth knowledge of veteran viticulturists.


What’s the one mistake you made in the cellar you would never repeat?

Not hiring younger more able bodies to do more of the grunt work!


What is your proudest achievement?

Being the father to two beautiful, smart and fantastically fun daughters.


What was your scariest vintage to date?

I don’t see any vintage as scary. I see them all as a gift from Mother Nature, and my job is to then execute the very best that I can. Vintage 2006 was my first “challenging” vintage – wet, cold, etc. – but I learned a lot from that vintage, and was able to apply everything I learned to vintage 2011. That’s how I see challenging vintages working, you learn from one then you apply it to the next.


What is your most prized possession?

My sense of humor and ability to remain calm in crazy situations.


What’s the oddest thing about you?

Strange, random OCD.


What song best sums you up?

Bob Marley – Stir it Up


What is your favorite memory?

The birth of my two daughters.


Which of the 5 senses is your strongest?

Actually, it is my sixth sense. As a winemaker, you use your 5 senses, but it is your 6th sense that is the game changer between a safe wine, a good wine, and a great wine.


What is your biggest motivation?

To be the best.


Which bottle of wine would choose to be stranded with on a deserted island?

A slightly chilled bottle of a great vintage of white burgundy from a great producer.


What is the difference between a good and great wine?

All the components (acid, oak, alcohol, fruit, pH, RS, etc.) meld seamlessly together. A wine that displays its varietal characters from a sense of place with layers, depth, character, and shows soul. A wine that is not “perfect,” not pure and clean. Has style. You can taste all that.


Name 3 individuals you would like to have dinner with.

My wife. Michelangelo. Steve Jobs.


Who is your winemaking hero?

Didier Dagueneau. Taken from us way too early.


What does the concept of “balance” mean to you?

A wine whose sum of all parts are all harmoniously in sync. And yes, a wine that is 14.5% alcohol can still be a balanced wine!


What is the one thing you want people to remember about your wines?

That if they were stranded on a deserted island and had one Pinot to drink, it would be MacPhail.


Best comment made about your wine? Was it by a consumer, trade or press?

ONE of the best I’ve every received was from a consumer: “Hands down the most food-friendly Pinot I have ever had. This is a wine any pinot geek should try. As a winemaker, I would call it ‘an epiphany’. As a guy who really likes to eat and drink, I would call it ‘delicious.'”  ~ JB


Ilona Thompson

Ilona Thompson is Editor-in-Chief at PalateXposure, a destination site for oenophiles, gourmands and luxury travelers. She also recently launched #Wine, a site dedicated to wines and spirits reviews, and #Photography, a site devoted to high-quality wine, food, and travel related photography.

  • Jim Caudill

    You can see the care he takes in all things…not many would be smart enough to list their wife as the first choice for dinner…a man to be admired, in all things.

    July 23, 2015 at 10:14 am

Post a Comment

Hey you!

Want to stay up-to-date with PalateXposure? Sign up today and get new post notifications delivered right to your inbox!